A new study from Jewelers Mutual® surveyed over 1,500 people in the United States who own fine jewelry. This fresh look inside the world of jewelry buyers and owners explores their feelings about jewelry ownership, how they wear and store their precious pieces, their fear of losing a treasured item, and what factors influence their jewelry purchases. Here are a few of the key insights.
Understanding the Key Factors in Jewelry Buying

Emotional Value and Sentimentality
Forget “diamonds are a girl's best friend,” our relationship with jewelry is more romantic than platonic. The survey reveals that “love” is the strongest emotion tied to buying or receiving jewelry, followed closely by “joy.” It's no surprise then that over half of the respondents admitted feeling a significant sentimental loss if they ever misplaced a piece. You can probably relate to this feeling. Those earrings Grandma gave you for your graduation, or the promise ring from your partner—these pieces become more than just accessories; they help us hold cherished memories of people and events close.
Quality and Craftsmanship
But finding that perfect piece isn't just about sentimentality; it's also about longevity. The survey shows that quality materials and craftsmanship are high priorities, and the reputation of the jeweler or brand plays a big part in buyer perception of quality. A large proportion of those surveyed said a brand's reputation for quality was a major buying factor. After all, you want a piece that will sparkle for years to come, and a trusted jeweler can help ensure that.
Price and Budget Considerations
Let's be honest, jewelry can be a significant investment. However, the survey found that budget realities don't stop people from wanting something special. Whether it's a splurge on a wedding band or a more budget-friendly everyday piece, everyone seeks that sweet spot between affordability and timeless design. There’s a piece that ignites desire for any budget.
Brand Reputation and Trust
In the world of jewelry, a trusted name can be a deciding factor for many jewelry buyers. The study indicates that buyers rely strongly on brand reputation when buying expensive jewelry, with over 50% saying so. For these buyers, a well-regarded brand assures quality and inspires trust.
Personal Style and Customization
These days, it's not just about following trends. The survey pointed to a growing desire for unique and personalized pieces. People want jewelry that reflects their own individual style and personality. Are you a fan of bold statement pieces or do you prefer something more delicate and classic? There's no right or wrong answer – it's all about finding what makes you feel good.
Ethical Considerations and Sustainability
Ethical sourcing and sustainability are more than just buzzwords; they're priorities for many modern jewelry buyers. The study indicates a growing segment of consumers prioritize eco-friendly and ethically sourced materials when buying jewelry. This trend reflects a desire to align their purchases with their values, with nearly 37% overall saying it's "very" or "extremely" important. There’s no need to settle for jewelry that goes against your values. Find a piece that aligns with your values and makes you feel confident and radiant. That’s your perfect match.
Occasion and Purpose of Purchase

Sure, weddings, anniversaries, and birthdays might spark the initial purchase. Celebrations, after all, are big reasons for many jewelry purchases. But perhaps the more compelling story is how often these treasures get worn. Forget the jewelry box. The survey reveals that most people wear their jewelry frequently—as in daily, weekly, or monthly. Only a tiny fraction (7%) reserve their pieces for special occasions. This suggests that jewelry is an integral part of their lives, expressing their personal style and keeping them close to cherished moments and relationships.
Because jewelry holds such significance, choosing the perfect piece becomes even more important. Let's face it, browsing for jewelry can be a treasure hunt filled with excitement – and maybe a touch of overwhelm. With so many dazzling options, how do you find the perfect piece that's both stunning and built to last? Don't worry, we've got you covered! Based on the survey, here are some insider tips to help you choose a piece you'll cherish forever
Practical Tips for Making Informed Jewelry Purchases
Research and Compare Options
Don’t rush into buying the first piece that catches your eye. Do some detective work! Compare options online and in stores, looking for quality indicators. This is where the famous 4Cs of diamonds (Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat weight) come in. But don't stop there! Also, pay attention to craftsmanship cues like securely set and well-cut gemstones and a finish that is well-polished and free from scratches or imperfections.
Consider Long-Term Value

This isn't just about a fleeting trend. Consider the long-term value and durability of the jewelry. You want a piece that will stay beautiful and stylish for years to come. Think about if you might want to pass it down as an heirloom someday or resell it later. Investing in quality materials and timeless design will ensure your jewelry continues to sparkle for generations.
Seek Expert Advice
Jewelers are there for a reason. Don't be afraid to ask questions and learn from their expertise. They can guide you through the selection process, explaining different materials, styles, and price points. A good jeweler will help you find a piece that perfectly complements your personal style and needs.
Protect Your Investment

You wouldn't drive your new car off the lot without insurance, so why treat your jewelry any differently? As the survey shows, over half of jewelry owners have experienced a loss or theft.
While renters or homeowners insurance might offer some coverage, it often falls short. Consider getting dedicated jewelry insurance from a reputable company like Jewelers Mutual for complete peace of mind. Here's where dedicated jewelry insurance shines. It provides comprehensive coverage in ways renters and homeowners policies were never designed to provide.
Jewelry is more than just an ornament; it's a tangible expression of our stories, aspirations, and values. Whether you're searching for a timeless piece to mark a special occasion or simply seeking to add a touch of individuality to your everyday style, understanding the complex factors and motivations that influence jewelry purchases empowers you to make informed decisions.
So, take your time, explore your options, and don't be afraid to ask questions. And don’t forget to protect your jewelry with personal jewelry insurance from experts like Jewelers Mutual.
With a little planning and research, you can find a piece that speaks to your heart and reflects your style and values becoming a treasured part of your personal story.
*The Jewelers Mutual study was conducted in April 2024 via an online survey through Qualtrics. A sample of 1,500 adults in the U.S. aged 20+ who own a piece of fine jewelry were recruited via an online research panel and surveyed via online self-completion.