Jewelers Mutual tops the list of the Best Jewelry Insurance Companies of 2024 published by Fortune Recommends. The endorsement features Jewelers Mutual as the Best Overall jewelry insurer after evaluating key factors such as company reputation, average rates and available policies. It also takes into consideration AM Best ratings, which measures a company's financial soundness. The review highlighted Jewelers Mutual's A+ rating as well as its 110-year history of expertise as a specialty insurer. The company stands out as an insurer of all types of jewelry with affordable rates and flexible deductible options as well as its offering to automatically adjust coverage based on current item value.